Files
VianoBugAnalysis/tests/fixtures/llm_rejections/20261020/joint-v2-dependencies/analysis.md
T

1.1 KiB

BUG-000020 joint v2, 2026-10-20

Original saved call documents, unchanged bytes. No credentials or full package archive. Initial interpretation omitted described_behavior[0].verification. The scoped patch added not_independently_verified without changing the statement text. Two candidates were reviewed as independent; one was explicitly replaced. Hypothesis acceptance then failed because premise interpretation_paths were missing from their parent dependency lists (all three candidates reference investigation_direction from a premise without declaring it above). These are existing, readable statement references, not invented evidence. Unioning validated explicit references is safe dependency bookkeeping, not semantic endorsement.

Unknown paths/sources, unread grounded evidence, unreviewed semantic dependencies and changed retained inputs remain rejected. Regression replays this corpus offline. Original replies stay immutable; normalized projections are derived. Retaining a candidate never accepts the whole set without the existing diversity, grounding and count validation.